Monday, April 16, 2018

Race and biology; Race shouldn't be a thing

As you enter the room, please do two things:

First, classify all of the objects on the table into categories.  You must have 2 or more categories and you cannot have a miscellaneous category.  Please be sure that you have assigned each object to a category.


Second, once you are finished with the objects, please answer these questions in order:
Q1: When referring to how people look, do you know what race means?
Q2: How many races are there?  Name them.
Q3: What is the definition of the word race as it applies to how people look?


This is the beginning of our unit on race.  Here is our packet for this unit.  Before we begin, it is important to define what we mean by "race" as well as some of the other terms that get confused with "race".

Ethnicity is a group of people linked by a common culture, ancestry and often associated with a geographic location.  For example, one might say that Italians are an ethnic group.  But an ethnicity doesn't have to apply to a country, it can be a group like Assyrians, Amish or Southern U.S. citizens.

Nationality is the country where someone is a citizen.  For example, if your passport is from the U.S. then your nationality is the United States, often referred to as "American".

Heritage is where a person's ancestors can be traced to.

Genotype is an individual's specific combination of genes that makes up their DNA.

Phenotype is the observable characteristics that an individual manifests from their genotype interacting with the environment.

Race is the idea that humans can be separated into distinct and discrete groups based on their biology.  For example, one might say that there are 3 races in the world: Asian, African and white.  The belief is that people can be separated into groups based on their biological traits such as, skin color, hair, eyes, nose, genes, etc...

HW:  Read Omi and Winant pages 2-8.  Be ready to answer questions about it and discuss it.

Warning:  Sociology sometimes "makes the familiar strange."  It sheds light on areas of our life that we never questioned before.  This can be an eye-opening experience that is sometimes difficult to accept.  Remember that we are like fish in water never having to question or notice the water.  This lesson may do that to you.  Trust the process.  Open your mind.

Traits
The first part of this metaphor explains how we classify the objects by trait.

Did anyone use different traits to categorize the objects? (size, shape, color)
What was the trait you used?  What were the categories you used to define the trait?  What objects did you put into each classification?
You will see two likely scenarios:
1. Students categorize the objects by different categories even though they use the same trait.  For example, if they choose the trait of size, they might categorize into either small, medium, large or small, medium, large, extra-large.  This shows that the categories used are subjective.
2. Students will categorize the objects by the same trait and same categories, but they will choose different items to put in each category.  For example, a ball that is classified as small by one student might be categorized as medium by another.  This illustrates that the delineations we use to separate categories are arbitrary.  Instead, if you lined all the balls up by a trait, they would look much more like a spectrum than distinct groups.

This is a metaphor for race and how we classify people.
Racial categories are hegemonic assumptions in the United States.  They are so ingrained in us that we never question them.  What constitutes different races?  Think about what traits people use to classify humans into "races."  If you lined people up from all over the world, they would resemble a spectrum instead of distinct groups.  People cannot be grouped distinctly into "races" in a scientifc, biological way.  If you tried to separate them based on a trait, the categories you create would be arbitrary and subjective.  For example, let's examine skin color. 

Skin color as an example of a trait.
Yes, skin color comes from different genetic combinations, but these combinations are not dividable into distinct groups.  Instead, the divisions we create using skin color are arbitrary divisions. If you lined up all of the people in the world according to a trait, the divisions would be less obvious. It would look more like a spectrum that changes gradually blending into one another.  See this evidence:

From the American Anthropological Association, this activity shows that deciding how to categorize people is arbitrary.

 


From a post on the soc images blog, this artist created a palette of colors showing that human skin is much more of a spectrum than distinct groups.  See this post for more about the artist and the project, including a Ted Talk.
Where would you divide up this palette into different races?















For an explanation on the biology of skin color, the article "Skin Deep" by Nina Jablonski and George Chaplin from Scientific American  explains the science behind skin color and how around the world, skin color would look more like a spectrum than distinct groups.  The map below from the article explains the correlation between UV light intensity and skin color.  Going back to our metaphor about the traits, do you see how the trait of skin color is a spectrum rather than distinct groups?



Nina Jablonski explains the significance of skin color in her Ted Talk here.


Before moving on, questions?

Questions about traits and why they cannot be used to categorize people into distinct races?


Other resources:

Click here to go to the Race; Power of Illusion website to see why there is no way of biologically separating people into "races"  based on physical appearance (including skin color, nose shape and head size), geographic origins or genetic similarities.












From the American Anthropological Association, here is an explanation about how genetic diversity spread out over time and how that led to varying populations of diversity but not distinct groups.  This explains that for nearly a century, scientists including anthropologists and biologists erroneously concluded that humans evolved from three distinct groups of hominids.  Known as the essentialist theory, this incorrectly posits that each group started as a "pure race" in three separate locations: Mongolia, Caucasia and Nigeria.   Eventually the groups intermixed but some individuals stayed more pure based on less mixing.  Using the scientific data that is available to us now, biologists, doctors, anthropologists and sociologists know that this is not true.  Instead of evolving separately, all humans began in Africa and gradually spread out across the globe.  However, some people still promote the essentialist theory.


From Harvard University's School of Biomedical Sciences, this explains more detail how genes work and why they can't be used to categorize people scientifically into"races".

Anatomy Class.  The idea that people can't be categorized biologically into races is difficult to accept and process because race is so ingrained in our society that we never question it.  It gets validation from many places, including our very own anatomy classes! (click here for a clarification of the anatomy forensic lesson).

Bill Nye explains why there is no way to define race biologically.

A 2017 article from the NY Times explains that the latest evidence from genetics is that there is not a connection between genes and race.

Jefferson Fish also explains how race doesn't make sense in the article titled "Mixed Blood" from Psychology Today, 1995.

For more info you can checkout the April 22, 2005 episode of Odyssey, a radio program that used to air on Chicago Public Radio. This episode about the genetics of race and if you listen carefully to the caller segment, you can hear a very interesting high school sociology teacher commenting. [Listen the program here (the good part is after 35:26)]


This article from Slate explains why ancestry kits do not explain race.



For your sociological mindfulness:
What are some assumptions you have had about race? Have you learned erroneous information regarding race? Why is this not a part of curriculum in American schools especially in light of the profound impact the idea of race has had on this country?  How do you reinforce the idea of racial categories?

Takeaway: (for more info see Ferris and Stein pages 215-218, 224-227)

How do humans around the world look based on different traits?

Are racial categories biological?

What is racial hegemony?

What is the essentialist theory?




Wednesday, February 28, 2018

Just Mercy Discussion and Unit 2 Review

As students enter class, please take out Just Mercy and look for examples of how the culture constructs the dynamics of the death penalty in the US.


For the Discussion, please keep in mind these criteria:

Just Mercy Chapters 3-4:

Thinking like a symbolic interactionist, how does the language used by the police affect Walter?  How can the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis apply to the interaction between Walter and the police? 

The norms and subculture of death row.

Norms of death row

Norms of trials in deep south.

How institutions reproduce culture.

How institutions like Supreme Court can change culture.

Culture of death penalty in AL and the institution of politics

Cultural values (usefulness, practicality, self-help, individualism) create norms of intolerance

Real culture vs. ideal culture

For thought:

-->
pg 90-91 “…we would never think it was humane to pay someone to rape people convicted of rape or assault and abuse someone guilty of assault or abuse.  Yet we are comfortable killing people who kill, in part because we think we can do it in a manner that doesn’t implicate our own humanity, the way that raping or abusing someone would.  I couldn’t stop thinking that we don’t spend much time contemplating the details of what killing someone actually involves.”



Review for Unit 2:

Identify the following reactions to culture:

            Culture Shock -
           
Ethnocentrism -

            Cultural Relativity –

How is culture like a fish bowl?


What is material culture?


Why is it important?
           

What are examples of symbolic culture? 


Why is it necessary to understand symbolic culture? 


            What is the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis? What are examples of it in our culture?


            “Social Time; The Heartbeat of a Culture” by Levine and Wolf. 


Norms 

Folkways

Mores

Taboos
           
            Moral holidays

Moral holiday places

Sanctions

What is a subculture?

            What is a counter culture?

            Kohl’s Values Americans Live By.
            
            Why are values important to a culture?

            What are the US values?

            What is ideal culture?

            What is real culture?

            What is a value cluster?

            What is a value contradiction?

Dan Buettner's Thrive.

-->

Thursday, February 22, 2018

Bemused in America and in Sociology...

Takeaway From Yesterday:
(number 5) Do you see how these values might shape your daily life? Can you give an example?

Today:  
Please open to page 22 and read the first artice "Supermarkets".  Annotate for examples of American values from the list below (or from your packet).

Today we talked about Bemused in America.  The article shows how someone from a country relatively similar to the United States, Germany(Western, industrialized, Democratic) can find many cultural differences that are quizzical and strange to him. These differences can be attributed to the different values that Americans have. For example, think about the Supermarket article. We like 24 hr stores because it is practical and efficient to have stores open all night and it allows us to control our time and shop whenever we want.  Here is the list of values (once again) that we compared to what the German author finds strange:

Kohl's "Values Americans Live By" is a really succinct explanation of American values.

American Values                                        vs.Other Cultures’ Values
Personal control/responsibility                   vs Fate/destiny
Change seen as natural/positive/Progress  vs. Stability/tradition
Time and its control                                     vs. Human Interaction
Equality/fairness                                          vs. Hierarchy/rank/status
Individualism/independence/freedom   vs. Group welfare/dependence
Self-Help/initiative                                    vs. Birthright/inheritance
Competition                                               vs. Cooperation
Future orientation                                     vs. Past orientation
Action/work                                                vs. “Being”
Informality                                                 vs. Formality
Directness/openness/Honesty                    vs. Indirectness/ritual/”face”
Practicality/efficiency                                 vs. Idealism/theory
Materialism/Acquisitiveness                        vs. Spiritualism/detachment
Achievement/Success                                   vs. Acceptance/Status Quo
Morality/judgement                        vs.Consequentialism/situational ethics


And here is how other cultures view American culture. Many cultures have "American" themed parties based on their perception of American culture.

And here is an Australian's perspective of strange things Americans do.

Wednesday, February 7, 2018

Odyssey Day 1 - Henhouse Prowlers


I was so excited to hear that the Henhouse Prowlers were performing at Odyssey 2018!  They are a blue grass band that I have seen over the years at other local performances (shout out to Capannari Ice Cream Shop in Mt Prospect).

The band explained the roots (culture) of blue grass and how the music does not include drums, but instead uses their voices and other instruments like a mandolin to create beats and harmonies.

The band not only performed but also spoke sociologically about their music and their experiences.  Aaron Dorfmann, SHS alum even gave sociology a shout out when he talked about following your passions.

The band spoke about travelling the world and how the US has a program to spread American culture around the globe.  The band has been to Eastern Europe including Russia and Turkmenistan and also to Africa including Niger and Mauritania.  They learned how hard it is to translate some things from English into other languages (as in their name - "prowler" presented a difficulty).  They also learned an appreciation for other countries' music.  In Niger they learned a folk song that they performed in the original language.

Tuesday, January 30, 2018

Google Trends Data

https://trends.google.com/trends/

search for google searches and how terms trended. 


Friday, January 26, 2018

Jenny Lee! Three perspectives of the military

Soc Mindfulness Takeaway (Day 4): Did you ever consider the military after high school?  Did you learn anything from Jenny's talk?


Jenny Lee stopped in to talk about her choice to join the Army and become a medic.

She spoke about how she emmigrated to America from Korea when she was only 5 and how all of her family had to serve in the Korean military.  She became interested in the military in high school but didn't feel like it was particularly encouraged by her peers and her school.  She spoke about how she liked the idea of enlisting because it streamlined the process and cut out a lot of variables like testing and applying for spots in ROTC. 

Jenny enjoyed basic training and actually thought it might even be harder than it was, but the biggest aspect of it was mental.  The Army has all kinds of different names for things like push-ups or jumping jacks.  Her basic included 10 weeks of training.  Her drill seargeant would mess with them by turning over their beds while they were training.  After basic, She was able to do her AIT (Advanced Individual Training) quickly in her MOS (Military Occupational Specialty), which was medic.   After 6 weeks, she was trained as an EMT and Army medic.

Here is my Grandpa who emmigrated from Italy at 16 years old.  He joined the US Army and fought in the Cavalry division during World War I.  After the war, he was able to become a citizen.



Here is my dad who had to serve in the Army two years because service was mandatory at that time.

These are my four great Uncles and my Great grandfather.  All four uncles served in WWII.

Thursday, January 25, 2018

Three Perspectives of Sociology

As you enter class, please open to page 27 and individually brainstorm answers the questions about conflict, functional and symbolic interactionist views.  Here they are:



Conflict:
Conflict theorists argue that the social order is based on coercion and exploitation.  They emphasize that sports reflect and even exacerbate many of the divisions of society.  Who has power in the sport?  How or why do they have power?  How do they use it?
  
Functionalism:
In examining any aspect of society, functionalists emphasize the contribution it makes to overall social stability.  Functionalists regard sports as an almost religious institution that uses ritual and ceremony to reinforce the common values of society.  Identify some of the groups present at the sporting event.  What functions does each group serve for the different individuals?  What are the negative functions (dysfunctions)?

Symbolic Interactionist View:
Interactionists are especially interested in shared understandings of everyday behavior.  They focus on how day-to-day behavior is shaped by and changed by distinctive social norms and values.  What are the important symbols in the sport?  Note that the symbols might be an object, but also might be an idea, an event or something else.  How do these symbols affect how the individuals act?


Also today:
HW: 
Read Just Mercy Intro and Chapters 1 and 2 for Next week.
Coming next week: Gang Leader For A Day.


Foundations of Sociology and the Three Perspectives

Three specific ways of having a sociological imagination are the three founding perspectives of sociology.  These three perspectives were the beginning of sociology.  All three of them were a reaction to the extraordinary changes of the industrial revolution taking place in Europe in the 1800s.  The founder of each of these theories is considered one of the founding fathers of sociology.

What are the groups and what functions do they serve? Are there negative influences from any of the groups (dysfunctions)? This is functional theory. It was developed by Emile Durkheim.

Who has power? How and why do they have power? How do they use it? This is conflict theory, developed by Karl Marx.

What are the important symbols? Note that the symbols might be an object, but also might be an idea, an event or something else. How do the characters act based on the symbols they find important? This is symbolic interactionism. I like to connect symbolic interactionism to Max Weber.

Can you relate any of these theories to your own life? How can the things you do be interpreted through one of these theories? For example why do you wear what you wear or why are you going to college or why do you stress yourself out to get "good" grades?

Takeaway:
How did the industrial revolution help sociology begin?          
           
Who are considered the founders of sociology?
           
What perspectives are they tied to?
           
What is the lens for each perspective?


For more information about the perspectives, please see Ferris and Stein (your textbook) pages 18-31.  

Thursday, January 11, 2018

In-n-out is not just for burgers! (And Stereotypes are not for categories.)

HW: Read and annotate Teen-Parent Conflicts

Takeaway from yesterday:  Were you surprised by the diversity of groups that students emphasized yesterday?  How about your own social network - do you see how you are not just an individual but a member of a community of groups?


In and out is not just for burgers, it is also for groups! Sociologists use the terms ingroup and outgroup to refer to groups that you are either a member of or not a member of. It is much easier to feel attached to the groups you are a part of and feel judgmental about your outgroups.

To illustrate this, today we separated the class into two different groups. Each group made a list of reasons why the other group was wearing what they were wearing. Every time I do this lesson, the reasons break down into judgments against the other group. For example:

This was a lesson about in-groups and out-groups. In discussing the different groups that makeup society, we see that there are in-groups and out-groups. An in-group is a group that you are a part of. You have membership in it, and because of that, you feel aligned to the group and you have ownership in it. By contrast, it becomes easier to judge the out-groups, or the groups you are not a part of.   There is myriad research on outgroup homogeneity, or seeing members of an out group as being similar to each other and having less individuality/differences than those of an ingroup.  As this semester goes on, be mindful of the groups that we talk about that you are not a part of. You must make a conscious effort to understand these groups. Try to become conscious of your judgments so that you can also consciously work against them. Watch this video clip about the famous "Angry Eye" classroom lesson done in the 1960s by teacher Jane Elliot. Think about how you may have judged out-groups in your own life. Also, think about how you become allied and bonded with your in-groups. Can you see how this happens in society? Can you think of examples in your own life?
 You can watch the whole video at Frontline's website.

And there is an updated version of this.  Jane Elliot returns to do the experiment with college kids.  It is called Angry Eye.  Here is the link to watch it on mediacast.

















Ingroup- outgroups and hate:
http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/psychology-hate-groups-what-drives-someone-join-one-n792941
"Trump's choice on Tuesday to blame "two sides" for Saturday's violence — rather than to specifically blame white nationalism/supremacy — could have "a serious emboldening effect," said Peter Simi, an associate professor of sociology at Chapman University in Irvine, California, who studies far-right hate groups...."We establish ourselves as a tribe, and we say this is the group for which I have a love for, for which I identify with...."Marsden cited Islamophobia as an example."There's a lot of hatred in the United States toward Muslims," she said. "One of the reasons is they don't understand the religion. ... There's a lot that they don't know, and that scares them, because there is a small part of Muslims who are violent, and that is what is driving the hate."That concept is known as the "in-group/out-group theory" — the idea that people tend to define themselves in social groupings and are quick to degrade those who don't fit into those groups."

Here is an ethnography by Patricia and Peter Adler about adolescent cliques and how they create ingroups/outgroups and stereotypes.


I think that the point of sociological mindfulness is becoming more aware of others and part of that awareness is an understanding of how we may have portrayed that group in our own minds.  So understanding the idea of in-group/out-group dynamics is easy but applying it to ourselves is the challenging part.  In this TED talk by Sam Richards, he explains how understanding outgroups might lead to a radical experiment in  empathy.  Check it out:

Now think about your own life.  What are your in groups?  What are the outgroups that you could become more aware of, more empathetic to?


Stereotypes

Please answer the following questions about Joel Charon's "Should We Generalize About People?"
1. Does Charon believe that people should generalize? Why/Why not?

2.What is the difference between a generalization and a stereotype?

3.  What are some groups that you belong to that have been stereotyped?  Have you ever experienced that?


After reading Joel Charon's "Should We Generalize..." hopefully, you realize that yes we must generalize because it is what makes us intelligent human beings. But our great strength as humans can also be a horrible flaw. If we do not generalize and categorize accurately then we run the risk of stereotyping. We must realize that although individuals can be categorized into certain groups, it doesn't mean that all individuals fit that group's generalization. Toward the end of the reading, Charon says,
"If we are open-minded and reflective, we can even evaluate how good or how poor our generalizations are, and we can alter what we know as we move from situation to situation."
This is both the task and the promise of sociology. Sociology challenges us to think about our generalizations and assumptions about what we know and it promises us that with proper thought and care we can understand people better. There is a poem I like that illustrates Charon's point. The poem called "The Cookie Thief" by Valerie Cox. We are all cookie thieves sometimes in how we erroneously use the categories that Charon talks about. When was the last time you were too quick to categorize or judge someone? Have you ever been stereotyped or judged wrongly?

Here is a link to a video called I am an American that shows the dangerous power that extreme stereotypes can lead to.
In this case, Islam is the example, but it could be any religion or ethnicity or whatever group. United States' history is littered with examples of groups that have been scapegoated and vilified. This is how  Muslims have been treated in many cases in post 911 America. But I have had so many Muslim students who prove that this is just a stereotype. And that is what this video is showing. There are caring, loving, neighborly Muslims all around us but extreme stereotypes lead us to only see the stereotype and ignore the reality.  Here is a link to a page hoping to end stereotypes about Muslims.

One example of people stereotyping quickly might be this Washington Post experiment in which Joshua Bell, violin virtuoso, played some of the greatest classical pieces ever written on one of the most expensive violins ever made. And yet few people noticed because he was dressed like an average guy and he was playing in the subway. Maybe people assumed he was a homeless streetperformer, so why stop and listen?

Some other examples of people shattering stereotypes are:

Here is an article in the Daily Herald about a motivational speaker who was born with no arms and no legs. We might categorize him as disabled, but we should be careful about the assumptions and stereotypes that go along with that category.









Likewise, here is a link to Nick Vujicic's website. He is a motivational speaker who also has no limbs.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/z43PXkvVC5c" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; encrypted-media" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Here is a video about Aaron Fotheringham, an "extreme sitter." Aaron has been in a wheel chair his whole life, but he sees it as an opportunity. Again, we should be careful of our stereotypes. Aaron is way more rad than I will ever be, but he is in a wheel chair and I am not. If you search youtube, you can see Aaron doing a double back flip! But there are also lots of videoes of him crashing over and over again and again. It takes hard work and lots of effort to become good at what you do.  Hard work was a theme in all of the above videoes.  And if you read the rest of Outliers, Gladwell makes the case that the most successful people spend ten thousand hours developing their skills.  The other theme that comes out in all of these videoes from Brett Eastburn to Aaron Fotheringham is that in order to find meaning in your life you must find a way to serve others.  Find a way to help other people.  You have talents.  Develop them and find a way to use them to help others.  That is your purpose.
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/z43PXkvVC5c" frameborder="0" allow="autoplay; encrypted-media" allowfullscreen></iframe>


Another great source about stereotypes is episode 362 from This American Life. Click here to listen to the episode where 5 people tell stories about stereotyping. Listen to the prologue about people with disabilities, and Act One about NY cops stereotyping people coming from Brooklyn.



Finally, when you feel like you have been stereotyped, how do you react? What do you do?Anis Mojgani suggests that you shake the dust. Checkout his slam poem. Here is a link to his poem in writing.











Here is a video about a different type of street performer that also challenges your assumptions about the category "disabled".  I love how these "disabled" people see their opportunity to teach others.  Their lessons seem to be similar:  The world doesn't owe you anything.  You owe yourself hard work and dedication to become what you want.  Find a way to help others/teach others.  Don't stereotype and keep an open mind.

Takeaway:

            What is the difference between a stereotype and a category?
           
            Should people generalize?

-->