1.8 In-groups, Outgroups, Generalizations, Stereotypes

While waiting, please review Joel Charon's "Should We Generalize About People?"

Action Item for next class:  Joel Best, "The Truth about Damned Lies and Statistics." 

Today's Lesson: 

Please sit in your designated areas.

 

In and out is not just for burgers, it is also for groups! Sociologists use the terms ingroup and outgroup to refer to groups that you are either a member of (ingroup) or not a member of (outgroup).

To illustrate this, today I separate the class into two different groups.   To put it another way, I create an ingroup and an outgroup for each student.  Each group made a list of reasons why the other group was in that outgroup. Every time I do this lesson, the reasons break down into judgments against the other group.

For example, in class I split students into 2 groups of students wearing spirit wear and those who were not. I asked each group to list as many answers as they could about the other group:

In just a few minutes, I created an in-group and an out-group.  

Ingroups are groups that an individual is in. You have membership in it, and because of that, you feel aligned to the group and you have ownership in it and you are more likely to trust it.  It is easier for individuals to recognize the diversity within their ingroups.

Out-groups, by contrast, are the groups that one is not a part of.  People tend to fear outgroups and judge them more than their own ingroups.  This can result in people unnecessarily fearing outgroups and scapegoating them.  They also tend to see outgroups as being less diverse and having less individuality/differences than those of an ingroup.  This is known as outgroup homogeneity.  Often, outgroups are based on a master status - a sociological term for a person's most salient group membership, or a group that defines the person to a society.

Some years I divide students by who is wearing jeans, or who is wearing hoodies or who is wearing gym shoes.  Regardless of how arbitrary the groups are, a similar result happens:  students generalize about the other group and pass judgments.  This is a small example of what happens with ingroups and outgroups.  Imagine how much we are affected by the ingroups and outgroups that we experience from the time we are young.   

Here is the Google Form for this lesson.

1.  What are some ingroups that you are a part of in your life?

Examples of how people can have fears and judgmental views of outgroups:

Religious outgroups

Outgroups can be used as a scapegoat to drum up fear and anger to galvanize support for leaders. This has been used unabashedly and unprecedentedly by Donald Trump, especially against Jewish Americans (ADL, JDCA, WaPo, Time, Charlottesville, Tree of Life Synagogue mass shooting) and Muslim Americans (PEW, Scientific American, CNN, USC, CAIR, Chapel Hill mass shooting, Murfreesboro).

This 2017 example from NBC news explains the outgroup effects clearly,

Much of hate is based in fear, said Dr. A.J. Marsden, an assistant professor of psychology at Beacon College in Leesburg, Florida — "basically, fear of the unknown, fear of what might happen and fear of anything that's different than you or falls outside your definition of what's supposed to be normal."
"We establish ourselves as a tribe, and we say this is the group for which I have a love for, for which I identify with." Marsden cited Islamophobia as an example,"There's a lot of hatred in the United States toward Muslims," she said. "One of the reasons is they don't understand the religion. ... There's a lot that they don't know, and that scares them, because there is a small part of Muslims who are violent, and that is what is driving the hate."
"That concept is known as the 'in-group/out-group theory' — the idea that people tend to define themselves in social groupings and are quick to degrade those who don't fit into those groups."

This 2017 NPR news story explains how terrorism gets used as an outgroup label,

There is a systematic bias in the way terrorism is covered "terrorism" label is often only applied to cases where the perpetrator is Muslim. And, those cases also receive significantly more news coverage.

"When the perpetrator is Muslim, you can expect that attack to receive about four and a half times more media coverage than if the perpetrator was not Muslim," 

Put another way, "a perpetrator who is not Muslim would have to kill on average about seven more people to receive the same amount of coverage as a perpetrator who's Muslim."
Perhaps these findings are not all that surprising to you. But there are disturbing implications for the way Americans perceive Muslims, and the way Muslims perceive themselves."

Quartz (2017) uses outgroups to explain why Americans are more afraid of 94 deaths from terrorism than from 301,797 deaths from guns,

According to the New America Foundation, jihadists killed 94 people inside the United States between 2005 and 2015. During that same time period, 301,797 people in the US were shot dead, Politifact reports.  But... Americans are more afraid of terrorism than they are of guns, despite the fact that guns are 3,210 times more likely to kill them.
Chapman University has conducted a Survey of American Fears for more than three years. It asks 1,500 adults what they fear the most. It organizes the fears into categories that include personal fears, conspiracy theories, terrorism, natural disasters, paranormal fears, and more recently, fear of Muslims.
In 2016, Americans’ number-one fear was “corruption of government officials”—the same top fear as in 2015.  Terrorist attacks came second.  In fact, of the top five fears, two are terror-related.  And number five is not fear of guns but fear of government restrictions on guns.  Fear of a loved one dying—whether by gun violence or anything else—came next.
... after the terror attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, people began flying less and driving more. The result, estimated Gerd Gigerenzer, a German risk specialist, was that 1,595 more Americans died in road accidents during the 12 months after 9/11 than would have otherwise....  

According to data compiled from the Centers for Disease Control, over 2005-2014, an average of 11,737 Americans a year were shot dead by another American (21 of them by toddlers), 737 were killed by falling out of bed, and nine were killed by Islamic jihadists—who in most cases were US citizens, not immigrants (Nearly twice as many Americans kill themselves with guns as kill each other).

 

Racial Outgroups

Jane Elliot's Brown Eyes/Blue Eyes illustrates racial outgroup attitudes

Jane Elliot, a teacher in the 1960s conducted an experiment in her third grade classroom to show the power of ingroups and outgroups.  

You can watch the whole video on Frontline's website.

And there is an updated version of this. Jane Elliot returns to do the experiment with college kids called Angry Eye. 

The power of recognizing our own outgroups

I think that the point of sociological mindfulness is becoming more aware of others and part of that awareness is an understanding of how we may have portrayed that group in our own minds. So understanding the idea of in-group/out-group dynamics is easy but applying it to ourselves is the challenging part.  But when we recognize outgroups, we can be more mindful about how we think about them and question where our assumptions about them have come from.  And maybe most importantly, we can bridge these outgroups by getting to know people who are part of our outgroups.

Powerful examples of how bridging outgroups can make a difference

Stranger at the Gate is a 2022 short documentary that shows the power of both outgroups and conquering their dangerous consequences through our shared humanity.

Here is the movie's website.

Here is a PBS story about the movie (Watch from :26 - 3:11)

Here is a preview from NPR's Here and Now.

Former marine Richard "Mac" McKinney was determined to bomb the local Islamic center in Muncie, Indiana. But the kindness he was shown there not only made him drop his plans, but eventually become a member of the community. The story is told in the new short film "Stranger at the Gate," directed by Josh Seftel.

Listen to it below:

Former student of mine, Amina Amdeen

Here is a Muslim former student of mine, Amina Amdeen on NPR's Story Corps who makes me so proud.  Listen to her story about the danger of outgroups and how bridging the gap can bring people together.

Here is NPR's coverage of the story.

Transforming a white supremacist
This episode of On Being demonstrates how creating an ingroup can also create empathy.

"We'd heard Derek Black, the former white power heir apparent, interviewed before about his past. But never about the friendships, with other people in their twenties, that changed him. After his ideology was outed at college, one of the only orthodox Jews on campus invited Derek to Shabbat dinner. What happened over the next two years is like a roadmap for transforming some of the hardest territory of our time."

More about Black's transformation in the 2018 Pulitzer Prize winning book by Eli Saslow called Rising Out of Hatred.

Cubs Joe Maddon and The Creation of Ingroups and Empathy

Cubs Joe Maddon's "Hazelton Integration Project" is a great example of how creating ingroups can help people bridge outgroups like race, immigration status and social class.  Essentially Coach Maddon did what I did in class: He created ingroups.  Except, he did it to create bonds between people who would have previously identified each other as outgroups. Watch this short summary here about how Maddon's project helped to create a sense of community and ingroup relationships.

As this semester goes on, be mindful of the groups that we talk about that are your outgroups. You must make a conscious effort to understand these groups and recognize the diversity within these groups. 

Research is important in helping us understand the unique aspects of out groups that we may not be familiar with.  Additionally, it is important to recognize our own biases connected to our in-groups so that this does not affect the objectivity of our research.

2.  Choose one of the examples above that you think is a good example of the importance of ingroups and outgroups.  Identify the two groups in the article.  how does one of the groups judge/stereotype their outgroup?

Applying ingroup/outgroup dynamics:

3.  Please share one or more examples from your own experience where you ay have had a misconception about an outgroup, but after getting to know someone from the outgroup, you had a new understanding of people from the group.

4.  Examine the research article that you found for this unit.  

Was the research focused on an ingroup or outgroup for you?   

5.  How might your research shed light on this group to avoid viewing the group with outgroup homogeneity?

Now think about your own life.  What are your in groups?  What are the outgroups that you could become more aware of, more empathetic to?

Categories and Stereotypes

After reading Joel Charon's "Should We Generalize About People?"

6.   According to Charon, is it okay to generalize? Why or why not?

7.  What is the difference between a generalization and a stereotype?

                        

After reading Joel Charon's "Should We Generalize..." hopefully, you realize that yes we must generalize because it is what makes us intelligent human beings. But our great strength as humans can also be a horrible flaw. If we do not generalize and categorize accurately then we run the risk of stereotyping. We must realize that although individuals can be categorized into certain groups, it doesn't mean that all individuals fit that group's generalization. Toward the end of the reading, Charon says, 

"If we are open-minded and reflective, we can even evaluate how good or how poor our generalizations are, and we can alter what we know as we move from situation to situation."

This is both the task and the promise of sociology.  Sociology challenges us to think about our generalizations and assumptions about what we know and it promises us that with proper thought and care we can understand people better.  

Apply the idea of ingroups/outgroups and categories/generalizations to the research that you found:

8.  What are the groups that are examined in the original research that you found? (Use the abstract)

9.  Does your researcher make any generalizations/conclusions about the group? (Use the abstract or conclusion)

10.  Does your researcher explain any nuances about the group that might help people from the outgroup think more critically about the group?

Examples of stereotypes and lessons we can learn from them:
Remember that without careful consideration, it is easy to stereotype entire categories - especially outgroups.  The reality is that there are very nuanced opinions about both sides of the issues:  

• Not in Our Name; American Jewish Activists Lead March to White House over Isarael's 'Genocide' 
• Not in Our Name; Jewish New Yorkers Speaking Out against 'Dehumanization' of Palestinians
• Letters to my Palestinian Neighbor by Yossi Klein Halevi, 2019
• Many Palestinians in Gaza Hate Hamas, October 2023
• Before the War Gaza's Leaders Were Deeply Unpopular, October 2023
• Palestinian protests of Hamas, August 2023
• Palestinians protest against Hamas in online event, January 2022
• Palestinian Protests against Hamas in streets of Gaza, March 2019
• How it Feels to Be Muslim in America
• How Does it Feel to be Jewish [in North America]

Be mindful of the way that you may perceive Jewish or Muslim Americans if they are an outgroup for you:

• Israeli policy does not reflect the feelings of all Jews and not even all Israelis
• Hamas’s terrorism does not represent all Muslims and not even all Palestinians

Stereotypes about Muslims
The video called I am an American that shows the dangerous power that extreme stereotypes can lead to.

In this case, Muslim is the category, but it could be a different religion, ethnicity or any other category of people.  United States' history is littered with examples of groups that have been scapegoated and vilified. This is how Muslims have been treated in many cases in post 9/11 America. But I have had so many Muslim students who prove that this is just a stereotype. And that is what this video is showing. There are caring, loving, neighborly Muslims all around us but extreme stereotypes lead us to only see the stereotype and ignore reality.  Here is a page from Indiana University called Muslim Voices which is trying to correct the stereotyping.

Lesson: Don't give in to outgroup homogeneity.  Even if you do not know the complex dynamics within an outgroup, be cognizant that those variations probably exist. 

Examples of stereotypes about differently-abled individuals 

Brett Eastburn
Brett Eastburn was born with no arms or legs.  Here is an article in the Daily Herald about Eastburn visiting a school in Mt. Prospect.  We might categorize him as disabled, but we should be careful about the assumptions and stereotypes that go along with that category.  Here is a Ted Talk by Eastburn and here is his book, I'm Not Missing Anything. 

 

Nick Vujicic
Another powerful differently-abled speaker is Nick Vujicic. He is a motivational speaker who also has no limbs.   Here is a video of him on youtube

 

Aaron Fotheringham

This is a video about Aaron Fotheringham, an "extreme sitter." Aaron has been in a wheelchair his whole life, but he sees it as an opportunity. Again, we should be careful of our stereotypes. Aaron is way more rad than I will ever be, but he is in a wheelchair and I am not.  If you search youtube, you can see Aaron doing a double backflip! But there are also lots of videoes of him crashing over and over again and again. It takes hard work and lots of effort to become good at what you do.  

Hard work was a theme in all of the above videoes.  And if you read the rest of Outliers, Gladwell makes the case that the most successful people spend ten thousand hours developing their skills.  The other theme that comes out in all of these videoes from Brett Eastburn to Aaron Fotheringham is that in order to find meaning in your life you must find a way to serve others.  Find a way to help other people.  You have talents.  Develop them and find a way to use them to help others.  That is your purpose.  And here is Aaron "wheels" Fotheringham at the 2016 Paralympics:


 

Here is the latest update from Wheelz on the BBC. 

Here is a video about a different type of street performer that also challenges your assumptions about the category "disabled".


I love how these "disabled" people see their opportunity to teach others.  Their lessons seem to be similar:  The world doesn't owe you anything.  You owe yourself hard work and dedication to become what you want.  Find a way to help others/teach others.  Don't stereotype and keep an open mind.

Lessons from differently-abled individuals:

• Accept yourself as a part of creation; your existence is the universe's confirmation to you that you matter.
• Develop your talents/desires.  Whatever you want takes hard work. It takes failure, discomfort and effort.
• Find ways to serve others.  Whenever you don't know what to do or when your life feels directionless or meaningless, find a way to serve others.  We all have talents that can help others.

11.  Choose one of the examples of stereotypes above.  What did you think about the example?  What is the category?  What is a stereotype of that category?  What are some accurate generalizations?

12.  Apply categories and stereotypes to the research article that you are examining:

What are the categories that your research article covers?

Are these ingroups or outgroups for you?
What are the generalizations in your research article?
Are there stereotypes that your research article dispels?

EXTRA:

Dealing with stereotypes
Finally, when you feel like you have been stereotyped, how do you react? What do you do? Anis Mojgani suggests that you shake the dust. Checkout his slam poem. Here is a link to his poem in writing.

Lesson from Mojgani: When you have been stereotyped, shake the dust.  Move on and don't let the dust settle on you.  Don't let it define you.

13. Have you ever been the victim or perpetrator of a stereotype?  What was the stereotype and category?  Share a personal example.

The Cookie Thief, a poetic example of judging
There is a poem I like that illustrates Charon's point. The poem called "The Cookie Thief" by Valerie Cox. We are all cookie thieves sometimes in how we erroneously use the categories that Charon talks about. 

Lesson: 
We have all been both the victim of stereotyping and the perpetrator of it.  Try not to be the cookie thief.

This American Life, radio episode about stereotypes 

Another great source about stereotypes is episode 362 from This American Life. Click here to listen to the episode where 5 people tell stories about stereotyping. Listen to the prologue about people with disabilities, and Act One about NY cops stereotyping people coming from Brooklyn.

Research on Ingroups and Middle School Cliques

Patricia and Peter Adler studied adolescents extensively and they concluded that the creation of cliques happens cyclically even before middle school begins and these can lead to prejudice and discrimination. Here is one of  Patricia and Peter Adler's ethnographies and you can read the abstract below:

Outgroups and the war in Iraq

In this TED talk by Sam Richards, he explains how understanding outgroups might lead to a radical experiment in empathy. 

HW REMINDER: Joel Best, "The Truth about Damned Lies and Statistics."