Remembering 9/11

HW: Read Joel Charon's Should We Generalize?

September 11, 2001 was earth-shattering for those who were living through it.  Over the years, stories and lessons have emerged from that day.  So, on the anniversary of 9/11, I want to post about it as a way of remembering those who died that day but also to learn something from that day.  

Rare 9/11 footage from the 29 minutes in between the collapse of the two towers from photojournalist Mark LaGanga on 60 Minutes including the man carrying briefcases "having a really bad day."

The story of the falling man photo from Time photographer.

Two French filmmakers happened to be filming NY firefighters on the job at the time of the 9/11 attacks.  Their footage became a documentary called 9/11 and was later purchased by CNN.  

The full documentary is available here at bitchute.  Also, PRI did a story about the documentary on the fifteenth anniversary of 9/11.  The PRI story is here and includes a link to the updated documentary.

A firefighter from Manhattan retells his experience working on 9/11 to the OWN network.

My Experience 

My own personal experience was that I was teaching sociology in a room in the 2900 hallway when Mr. Frantonius came into my room in a hurry and said turn on your TV, the pentagon is on fire and the world trade center is on fire.  We turned on the TV to live coverage and we watched the mayhem including live footage of the crash into tower 2 of the World Trade Center.   I remember leaving and trying to figure out what to tell my students in non-western cultures class third period.  Then, I had to travel to the other building and going outside was transformational - it was a beautiful sunny September day and the birds were singing oblivious to the horrors that people were going through.  It was comforting to think of creation and nature being so at peace.  Anyway, I had to teach the rest of the day despite the turmoil of emotions that we all experienced.  Looking back, there are some lessons to be learned and I think they all relate in part to sociology, certainly when considering sociological mindfulness.

Disaster and Altruism

One way to think about 9/11 is through all of the love and heroism that was displayed during that traumatic day. There are so many stories of strangers helping each other and displaying unbelievable acts of courage and love - from the Port Authority of NY to the police, fire and other first responders to those who just happened to be at work that day and found themselves in a situation to help others.  Lee Clarke's 2001 study is one sociology study (for more info. see Ferris and Stein 448-450) of how people in a disaster tend to help each other.  We are wired for being cooperative and helping others. (More on this in our unit on socialization.)  It was an incredible illustration that when life seems senseless and unbearable, we can ask ourselves, "How can I serve?" In other words, what can I do to help my fellow people and how can I make this world a bit better. That gives meaning to our life just as it did to those people on 9/11. Sociologically, humans were made to need each other. 

My Mom's Experience at O'Hare
One example from my own life this day was my mom who worked at O'Hare Airport as a ticket agent. After the attacks, O'Hare was closed down and all the employees and passengers were being forced to evacuate. As this was going on, an elderly woman who had trouble seeing approached my mom and asked what she should do. My mom said that the airline would get a hotel room for her. The woman said that the nearest available rooms were in a far suburb away from the airport. So, my mom said, "You know what? You come home with me." And she did. This total stranger lived with my parents for four days! It was that kind of caring that these horrible events brought out. 

The Man in the Red Bandanna

Welles Crowther was another hero on that day. His story from ESPN is here.  

"Everyone who can stand, stand now.  If you can help others, do so."

Man with Red Bandanna website here which includes a trailer for a documentary about Welles.

Boatlift

Here is a video displaying some of this heroism and caring in the largest water evacuation in history.

Gander, Newfoundland
Here is another example about the people living in the small town of Gander in Newfoundland, Canada and how they came to the aid of hundreds of people. 

Stereotypes

One of the most direct ways that I think sociologically about 9/11 is in the discussion of stereotypes and categories. I posted about this here too. The attackers on 9/11 claimed to be Muslim but that should not be turned into a stereotype about all Muslims. There is a powerful video that illustrates how Muslims were stereotyped after 9/11 and the video also shows how these stereotypes are shattered when you see the full spectrum of Muslims in America.
The speech in that video illustrates the same type of racist, intolerance that led to the attacks on 9/11. I think that September 11 can be a day to remember that we are all connected and we all share this world, and this can be done in peace and tolerance, even if we are not all in agreement. Don't let the hurt and anger give way to stereotypes, injustice and hatred.

Here is a Moth story from Khalid Latif, an imam who was a student in NYC on 9/11.

In fact, one of the first people killed by this hatred and ignorance was not even Muslim.  Balbir Singh Sodhi was killed outside of the gas station that he owned in Mesa, Arizona on September 15, 2001.  He was killed because he was a Sikh and wore a Turban.  He was targeted because he dressed differently and his killer assumed (outgroup homogeneity) that he was not American and therefore a muslim and therefore a terrorist. 

Here is an NPR Storycorps interview about Mr. Sodhi's brothers.
Here is a CNN story about how Mr. Sodhi's brother has chosen forgiveness.

Here is a story from American University about how life changed for Muslims and Sikhs after 9/11.

It is our nature to love one another and be cooperative. We often lose sight of that in our individualistic culture. Here is a quote from two survivors of 9/11:

On a personal level, Mel and Lisa learned several lessons from that day. “Be patient, be tolerant and above all tell people you love them every single day,” Lisa said. “Hate drove that day. The lesson is to never hate. Hate does damage. People didn’t need to die that day.”

Read more: http://rapidcityjournal.com/thechadronnews/latest/couple-say-lessons-are-patience-tolerance-love/article_ef9e8656-d8ca-11e0-8657-001cc4c03286.html#ixzz1Y3NoAXGC 

Sociological Mindfulness and the Human Experience

Steve Osborne's "Takedown Day" from the Moth storytelling slam.
And one last story by former NYPD cop, Steve Osborn who helps us understand what it's like to be a cop on most days and how that translated to 9/11.  And if you watch his story until the end, you see a great example of how even a little kid (Alex) can make a difference in someone's life.  It's a reminder to be sociologically mindful.

Education as Functional Institution

Here is an NYT article about how 9/11 is taught around the world revealing that curriculum and textbooks are often a function for the society that they are in.